Tags
Leonard Cohen: Old Ideas – god bless the man who will not rest.
Ok! I’m a HUGE Leonard Cohen Fan. But I have to confess to being a little disappointed with the last few albums. I think there is a return to something from the old days here. With songs like Anyhow and Darkness and Going Home I hear the seeds of that old Leonard – the poet wrapped up inside the song. He turned a corner with The Future that meant I kept running back to the old songs and couldn’t quite connect with the newer albums. This feels like a return. Not all of the songs are perfect Cohen, but an awful lot of them are. (for me the stand out is Anyhow – is it right to lust after a man that age?) He’s so timeless, he’s so reliable. He’s ultimately, just so very very perfectly generous.
The Guardian did a fantastic interview with the man himself. If you haven’t read it, check it out. I also reviewed Songs of Love and hate (still my favourite LC album) so be sure to check that out as well.
Going home
“This has the feel of death. It opens with “I love to speak with Leonard. He’s a sportsman and a shepherd. He’s a lazy bastard living in a suit.
But he does say what I tell him, even though it is unwelcome. He just doesn’t have the freedom to refuse.”
And bang just like that – we’re into another Leonard Cohen album. He calls himself a brief elaboration of a tune. Is going home about death or is it perhaps going home to song? This feels like a sister song to Tower of Song. Something about coming back to the music always lights Leonard Cohen up. This song sets us up to understand the words aren’t Leonard’s. They come through him from some other place. He claims he is the carrier and the one who doesn’t have the freedom to refuse.
He wants to write a love song
An anthem of forgiving
A manual for living with defeat
A cry above the suffering
A sacrifice recovering
But that isn’t what I want him to complete
I want to make him certain
That he doesn’t have a burden
That he doesn’t need a vision
That he only has permission
To do my instant bidding
That is to SAY what I have told him
To repeat
Amen
Tell me again when my thirst is quenched and my ears are ready to listen. Tell me that you love me. Amen. In this song Leonard Cohen tiptoes his way through the vices of men. The lack of virtue and the idiocy of wanting something you are not ‘good’ enough to have. ‘Tell me again when I’ve seen through the horror. Tell me again, tell me over and over.” This is the miracle of love. The miracle of being wanted despite your vices. Part way through the song a lovely lonely horn breaks through here to bring a dreamy jazz soaked feel to the lightness of a Leonard trip with his trademark female backing vocals. Nothing fancy, just Leonard, his pain, his remorse and his music.
Show me the place
Show me the place where you want your slave to go.
There were chains, so I loved you like a slave.
We now have that dark voice back. He can make it so deep and gravelly and then he can take it to the soft lilting place of Amen. A simpler, softer song this time, but posited against the deeper voice makes this seem more internal. He’s inward bound here. Again we have the two sides of love. The willingness to be a slave and the agonizing chains that make one a slave. Initially when this song started I thought he was in full-blown ‘religious’ mode, but soon he turns it around (as only Leonard Cohen can) to make himself out to be the Sacrifical lamb on the altar of love. This is a real ‘just like the old days’ Leonard Cohen song. The likes of which I haven’t heard for ages. This is a gorgeous gorgeous song.
Darkness
The rumbling rambling guitar sounds like the Leonard of old here at the start. Then he lurches in one of those deliciously cynical songs we love so much. The Darkness, gets him every time, but not in that depressed sad Leonard way. Here we have a funky Hammond organ backing up a more up beat feel to off set the deep dark lyric. “winning you was easy, but darkness was the prize’.
….. it was drinking from your cup,
I got the darkness
from your little ruby cup
I said ‘is this contagious?’
You said ‘just drink it up’
Anyhow
Oh My god – this is STUNNING! There is a deep bluesy feel here that he is completely comfortably with. The lyrics roll off his tongue wrapped in that melting voice of his. Cohen whisper-speaks this bringing its sublime beauty to the surface and getting slightly out of the way of the piano and snare. Check the lyrics:
I know it really is a pity
The way you treat me now
I know you can’t forgive me
But forgive me anyhow
The ending got so ugly
I even heard you say
You never ever loved me
But could you love me anyway
I dreamed about you baby
You were wearing half your dress
I know you have to hate me
But could you hate me less?
I used up all my chances
And you’ll never take me back
But there ain’t no harm in asking
Could you cut me one more slack?
I’m naked and I’m filthy
And there’s sweat upon my brow
And both of us are guilty
Anyhow
Have mercy on me baby
After all I did confess
Even though you have to hate me
Could you hate me less?
It’s a shame and it’s a pity
I know you can’t forgive me
The ending got so ugly
You never ever loved me
Dreamed about you baby
I know you have to hate me
I’m naked and I’m filthy
And both of us are guilty
Anyhow
Have mercy on me baby
Crazy to love you
For me, this song had a real Tom Waits feel to it. I thought of Tom Waits several times through this album, but mostly in this track. This is another classic Cohen track. Beautiful, that soft spoken voice reaching out for the heart and tugging gently. He does that lament for love so very very well. I had to go crazy to love you. Isn’t that the way we all have to go when we’re in love?
I’m tired of choosing desire
I been saved by a blessed fatigue
The gates of commitment unwired
And nobody trying to leave
Sometimes I’d head for the highway
I’m old and the mirrors don’t lie
But crazy has places to hide in
That are deeper than any goodbye
Come Healing
This has a hymn like feel to it. Harmony and that gentle organ in the background add weight to the hymnal feel of the lyric. The sing is filled with the health and power of the redemptive force of a religious call. Leonard Cohens lyrics are filled with the sadness and longing of one who sees themselves as dirty – unhealthy. It’s the redemptive power of love that moves him just as it is the redemptive power of the spirit of whatever church it is that he loves that drives him forward.
And lets face it – appears to have some sort of longevity thing going for it.
Banjo
Banjo and Leonard Cohen is not a match I make automatically. The poet is playing here, using alliteration to bounce him through a lovely song about a banjo bouncing on the sea. the song itself bounces cheerfully along as though we were on that shore watching that banjo make its way. Our ominous friend asks us where it came from – why is it on ocean? Did it fall from someones shoulder or did it come from someones grave. Then we have a characteristic change of direction. Suddenly we know he isn’t talking about the banjo anymore:
It’s coming for me darling
No matter where I go
Its duty is to harm me
My duty is to know
and we are reminder again that we are sitting here with a poet – not just a musician.
Lullaby
We have a sweet lilting country feel to this no-twist song that is straightforward and simple.
Sleep baby sleep
There’s a morning to come
The wind in the trees
They’re talking in tongues
If your heart is torn
I don’t wonder why
If the night is long
Here’s my lullaby
Here’s my lullaby
One of the things I adore about his lyrics is his ability to not question the sadness in his lovers eyes. He just accepts it as an inevitable part of life. He’ll say he’s sorry if it he caused it, but for the most part, he accepts that it will exist. No efforts to repair, no attempt to burden himself with worry. Just pure, respectful acceptance.
Different Sides
We’re manifesting songs like Everybody KNows here. It’s that universal in the personal when lovers argue. We’ve got a light and playful piano literally tickling the ivories for us in the background along side that understated Hammond organ. It’s a modern take on a seamless performer who has been delivering the goods for decades now.
You want to live where the suffering is
I want to get out of town
C’mon baby give me a kiss
Stop writing everything down
Both of us say there are laws to obey
Yeah, but frankly I don’t like your tone
You want to change the way I make love
I want to leave it alone
Pingback: My favorite Leonard Cohen Album: Songs of Love and Hate. « Lisa Thatcher
Good review, clearly you are a big fan! I definitely liked the album more than 2004’s Dear Heather, I don’t think Old Ideas is as haunting as previous albums(only time will tell), but was glad, as you were, to listen to some acoustic stuff. His voice always worked well with an acoustic guitar.
Definitely a return to form for me in terms of about 50% of the LP. I just reviewed the album myself, where I shared my opinions+fav tracks.
LikeLike
Yes I would agree Chris – and you’re right, I am a big LC fan.
Your review is excellent – everyone should check it out – http://moviesandsongs365.blogspot.com.au/
I liked the point you made about setting the bar so high its difficult to measure up and I agree with your
Johnny Cash comment.
It will be very interesting to see what LC’s next album can do.
LikeLike
I’ve got to admire both the extensive catalogue of album reviews on this blog and the quality of this one. I bought this on vinyl having only really started to fully appreciate Leonard’s contribution to music and listening to it alongside recording from a much younger man makes for such stark comparisons! Its truly amazing to me that after all these years he’s still writing songs this good, utterly unique in my eyes!
Will have to check more of these reviews out when I have time
LikeLike
Thank you for your compliments and welcome to the blog. Most of all, so happy to hear from another LC fan. My favourite album is Songs of Love and Hate.
He’s the man.
🙂
LikeLike
Thanks! I stumbled across your blog when I saw your piece on The Master. I’m currently working on a review of Greenwood’s score, thought your review writing on the film was pretty awesome! I’m not sure which is my favourite album – to be honest the album that got me into him proper was Songs from the Road, the dvd and cd release of his 2010 world tour I think?
Lover, Lover, Lover and Closing time as live performances just blew me away, what a treasure!
LikeLike
Yeah – he really is all that. I went to that 2010 tour – he was wonderful.
Thanks for the comments – I’ve closed my comments these days … I get scared when they are open, but please leave a link to your blog here so that readers can hop over and check out your review. 🙂
LikeLike
Thanks Lisa! I’ve just finished my review.
I don’t really have enough followers to fear any negative feedback yet, so for now my comments are open.
Here’s the link to my review of Jonny Greenwood’s score for The Master:
LikeLike
Also I really liked your Punch Drunk Love review, I’ve never seen in myself but like you am planning to watch my way through PTA’s back-catalogue! Loved the writing about the collab between Anderson and Brion too. I’m a massive fan of Brion after Eternal Sunshine. Such talented folk!
LikeLike